Perfect Pecan Pie

Posted on Apr 16 2012 - 9:32am by Barry C. Parsons
Perfect Pecan Pie

Perfect Pecan Pie

Trust a true pecan pie lover who has been using this recipe for over 30 years. I’ve never had better.

Pecan Pie is my favorite pie. I’ve been making it for 30 years or more and it is always on my table on Christmas Day as a treat for myself and  some other Pecan Pie lovers in my family. I am a bit of a nut nut I must admit which accounts for a large part of why I love it so much.

Perfect Pecan Pie

Perfect Pecan Pie

Although my love for this pie is well established, we have a very intermittent relationship because I simply cannot resist this one so I don’t make it all that often. It is one of those desserts that I covet and uncharacteristically do not willingly share. If it is in the fridge, it calls to me and I find myself making several trips , knife in hand, to cut small slivers which I eat throughout the day. I would probably polish an entire pie off in two days in tiny slices if left to my own devices. Little slices don’t count anyway….right? 

 

Like this Pecan Pie recipe?

 
Check out our collection of Rock Recipes Top Ten Most Popular Pies

Perfect Pecan Pie

Perfect Pecan Pie

 

 
Perfect Pecan Pie
 
Prep time
Cook time
Total time
 
Making the perfect pecan pie is easier than many people think. This is the same easy recipe that I've used for decades. Make sure you are using a large enough pie plate as well or the filling will be too thick, a shallower pie is better for setting. I bake it in a 10 inch pie plate or even an 11 inch tart pan.
Author:
Recipe type: Dessert
Serves: 12 servings
Ingredients
For the butter pastry
  • 1 cup very cold butter cut in small cubes
  • 2 ½ cups flour
  • 2 tbsp brown sugar
  • ½ tsp salt
  • ¼ to ⅓ cup ice water + 2tbsp white vinegar added (Only enough liquid to make a dough form.)
  • 1 tsp vanilla extract
For the filling
  • 4 large or extra large eggs (or 5 medium, or 6 small)
  • 1 ½ cups lightly packed brown sugar
  • 1 ½ cups dark corn syrup
  • 2 tsp vanilla extract
  • ½ cup melted butter
  • 1½ cups pecan halves
Instructions
For the butter pastry
  1. Using a food processor or a pastry blender cut cold butter into flour, brown sugar and salt until mixture resembles a coarse meal. Small pieces of butter should still be visible.
  2. Pour vanilla into cold water then pour over the mixture and work in by tossing with a fork until dough begins to form. Use your hands as little as possible and work the dough as little as possible.
  3. Divide dough into 2 balls, flatten into 2 rounds, wrap in plastic wrap and place in the refrigerator to rest for a minimum of 20 minutes.You can make your dough the previous day but make sure you take it out of the fridge for 10 minutes to warm slightly before rolling out. (This pastry recipe makes sufficient for two pie crusts, so wrap one of the pastry rounds tightly in aluminum foil and freeze it for later.)
  4. Roll the dough into a 12 - 14 inch round and place in the bottom of a 10 inch pie plate.
  5. Push the dough into the corners and ensure that it is not stretched at all or it will shrink from the edge.
  6. Trim dough to a half inch past the edge of plate.
  7. Fold the ends under and finch with fingers or fork to shape the edges into whatever design you like best.
  8. Place in freezer while you prepare the filling.
To make the filling
  1. Whisk the eggs, brown sugar, corn syrup, vanilla and melted butter together until the brown sugar is dissolved.
  2. Stir in the pecans.
  3. Bake for 50-60 minutes at 375 degrees F (350 F for glass bake-ware) or until the center is set and jiggles like jelly. Cool completely before serving.
Notes
The amount of eggs is important in this recipe. I generally use extra large eggs in this recipe. If not using the largest size eggs available, it shouldn't hurt to add an additional egg.
In reading some comments from readers I suspect all corn syrup is not the same in all places. Here it is very thick. Thicker than molasses at room temperature. If your corn syrup isn't that thick be sure to add that extra egg as insurance that the pie will set.
Make sure you are using a large enough pie plate as well or the filling will be too thick, a shallower pie is better for setting. I bake it in a 10 inch pie plate or even an 11 inch tart pan.
As long as the crust doesn't burn, an extra few minutes in the oven should not be a problem if needed as well.

Leave a Reply

53 Comments on "Perfect Pecan Pie"

Notify of
avatar

Sort by:   newest | oldest | most voted
Anonymous
Guest

Making this pie right now but the directions say to divide the dough in 2 and refrigerate but nowhere does it say how to recombine them. This part is too vague. Is it for 2 crusts or should they be combined while rolling them out… hmmmm.

Barry C. Parsons
Guest

Sorry, I should have added that you can freeze one for later.

Rebecca
Guest

hi there – could you further explain this sentence: Trim dough to a half inch past the edge of plate. Fold the ends under and finch with fingers or fork to shape the edges into whatever design you like best.

I am confused as to how to do this step.

Also, with the above comment, does this mean that I could halve the recipe to make dough for one pie rather than 2?

Barry C. Parsons
Guest

Yes, half the pastry recipe if only making one pie, or freeze the second round for later.

Just trim and flute the edges for the pie in any way you like. The pie in this photo was baked in an edge-less pan, so it wasn’t necessary.

allison
Guest

Hi there,
I can’t seem to find what temperature to cook this at. Help please!!!

Sarah
Guest

Any recommendations for baking this in high altitude?

judy
Guest

Is the recipe for the filling enough for 1 or 2 pies

Kimberly Smith
Guest

I tried this recipe and for some reason my filling never set. I cooked it according to directions and when it was cooled completely I cut into it and the filling was still liquid. so I baked it some more and cooled it again and when I cut it the second time it was still liquid. I ended up throwing the whole thing away. The flavor was great it just never set. any suggestions?

Julia Gum
Guest

Barry, This was the most amazing recipe! Thank you for sharing it.

Carla
Guest

Oh my goodness!! I just made this pie and it is AMAZING! No wonder you only make it once in awhile, I am having trouble not eating it as we speak. Thank you for an awesome recipe!

Teri
Guest

Hi,

I’ve tried this recipie similar in the past, and I too had problems with the filling not setting. I thought the liquid, butter , eggs and syrup seemed to add up to too much liquid?

Any tips?

Naris
Guest

Do you think you could substitute the dark corn syrup for light?

ann
Guest

Do you refrigerate pecan pie if made a few days before serving

JSherman
Guest

If I use a frozen crust from the store should I bake it first?

Jenny
Guest

This recipe looks delicious but since I don’t have a food prossesor, but can I use anything else to make the dough. I have a Kitchenaid mixer? Any help would be greatly appreciated!!

Sara
Guest

I did the filling recipe for my own crust, and I did a smaller 8 inch pie. NO CHANGES TO THE FILLING and it only fit in one pie. So, make sure you have enough ingredients to do two. Because, I had to make a trip to the grocery store to get more corn syrup and pecans.

ashley H.
Guest

Do I grease the pie pan.

Christy
Guest

I’m trying this recipe right now, hope it turns out good! It’s for our thanksgiving dinner tomorrow ….wish me luck going in oven now.

Julia Gum
Guest
Recently, I asked my son if he would like me to bring this pecan pie recipe for Thanksgiving. He said, “No, not on Thanksgiving but would you bring it on Friday?” Quickly, I asked, “Why on Friday?” His response, …”Because everyone will be gone on Friday so I can eat more of the pie. Mom, it would be just fine to pick up a cherry pie for Thanksgiving.” His humor was cute…but very much likes YOUR recipe! Thanks again. Have a Happy Thanksgiving with your family! Many of us appreciate your gift of cooking.
Korea
Guest

I made 2 sets of filling and placed both in the oven, been over an hour and it’s like soup and really liquidy.. Followed the recipe exactly as it is- but I dont know what happened): I’ve been baking all day.. And it’s night. I’m so sad now ):

Kaelynn
Guest

I made it and it looks great…I am taking it to my in-law’s for a late Thanksgiving dinner tomorrow night (later today, it’s 12:00am) so I can’t taste it. My only concern is that the crust appears to be burnt. I guess I need a crust cover or put foil over it while it bakes. Any suggestions? My husband and his dad LOVE pecan pie so I tried it for the first time.

Mary
Guest

My pie also had a liquid center. Added all ingredients as instructed. Used xtra large eggs, The crust was quite brown so I couldnt bake any longer. Luckily I had another dessert ready. I wonder if I mixed the ingredients for too long?

Kristel
Guest

Made the filling and added to a pre made pie crust. It was delicious but a little runny, any suggestions on how to avoid that?

Karen
Guest
I have pecan pie in the oven as I type this. I used store bought shells (busy momma here!).. and filled 2 of them. I have never made pecan pie before – had it or the first time this year. Decided we would have it for Christmas. I am very excited about it. It was easy to make. I hope it sets up nice for dessert tomorrow. Reading the reviews I do have to wonder if corn syrup is different in the US as compared to Canada. The corn syrup I used actually has a pic of pecan pie on… Read more »
Jackie
Guest

hi what kind of vinegar do you mean? I have white wine vinegar or distille white vinegar.

Lisa Steuerwald
Guest

Hi, I am from Australia and my husband brought back some corn syrup from Canada for me so I could bake this recipe. I am reading the comments about the uncooked filling and hoping my corn syrup is going to work. The brand is Crowns. Will that one work? what brand do you use?

Lauri H
Guest
I made two pies, added two extra eggs total to filling since I had 9 inch plates. Pies really puffed up 3/4 way through baking and they turned out nice, especially for my first pecan pies. I’m wondering though, my crusts are a bit soggy on the bottom even though the filling is set. Should I have added more egg? I could make the crust a little thicker maybe. Your pic shows a nice bottom crust so I know it’s possible, just have to figure out how to do it right. Thanks for your recipe! One more thing-these do not… Read more »
Jo Ann Cummings
Guest

Are you using light brown sugar? Can’t wait to make!

wpDiscuz